When picking out a gift for a baptism, it's important to consider: Religious reference Baptism is a religious ceremony, so religious imagery like crosses or Bible references are appropriate gift ideas. Elegance Baptism is a formal ceremony, and although gifts may be cute, they should reflect that formality. Keepsake These gifts are meant to last and be cherished. Go for something of high quality that can be appreciated over a person’s lifetime and perhaps passed down as a family heirloom.